With Remembrance Day on the horizon, Canadians are looking to express appreciation for the country’s veterans, perhaps hoping to don war medals earned by their deceased relatives. But this last week, many Canadians learned that a little-known law actually forbids that gesture of respect and tribute. Article 419 of the Criminal Code of Canada prohibits “the wearing of orders, decorations and medals by anyone other than the individual who was awarded the honour.” Within a few years we’re going to have a large amount of medals that were awarded to Canadians, including the Victoria Cross, that no one can display.’ Jeff Rose Martland, executive director of veterans group Our duty Jeff Rose-Martland, executive director of the Canadian veterans group Our Duty, says his constituency generally opposes the idea of people wearing the medal of a living veteran. When it comes to deceased veterans, it’s been pretty universal. I myself believe that medals suggested the medals could be put in a small display case and carried at Remembrance Day services rather than being worn when and if a family feels it just.
The law came to light after Our Duty announced a campaign called “Veterans Among Us”. which sought to raise awareness of Canada’s 900,000 veterans. While fielding questions about war medals, Our Duty learned of the 91 year old statute prohibiting someone else from wearing of medals received by living or deceased veterans. The organization promptly issued a release advising its constituents not to wear the medals of family members, as the act would be a criminal offence. Introduced in 1920, the statute was largely intended to deter people from impersonating returning war veterans, who were entitled to benefits and incentives (like jobs) in the years after service. The statute does not set out a specific penalty, but for summary conviction offences, the penalty is a maximum of six months imprisonment as well as a $ 5,000.00 dollar fine.
Commonwealth nations like Great Britain and Australia have similar restrictions on wearing the medals of a living veteran. The consequences are fines or up to six months in jail. But both countries relax the law if the veteran is deceased. Our Duty would like to have the Canadian law amended. Over the last few decades, there have been backbench motions to change the statute, but they were quickly voted down. Ultimately there is a warranted concerned that this old law stands in the way of giving veterans their proper due of respect while at the same time not forgetting the history of those which have served – mind you many veterans which pass on most often which to be buried with their full attire along with their medals of which they earned while serving.
As we approach a hundred years past the end of World War I. We don’t have any Great War veterans left, the World War II veterans are passing, and within a few years we’re going to have a large amount of medals that were awarded to Canadians, including the Victoria Cross, that no one can display – I would tend to think that it’s an adaptation within how we handle the manner in which we respect those of which have served.
~ Lest We Forget ~
Hmmmmm - carrying in a case seems a fair compromise. But, I'm not the one having to choose between wearing and carrying.
ReplyDeleteI did not have a picture yet I thought I would write on this very subject Susan.
ReplyDeleteActually, here they can be displayed -- just not worn. We have the flag and medals given to my brother-in-law. We may display in a case, but no one may wear them as they may appear to have been earned, which they were not. I agree that wearing another's badges of honor truly is dishonorable.
ReplyDeletePerhaps donating a display case to a library or museum designed to display great works.
What I consider to be more important is---can we build a lasting peace among all nations? A peace, not entered into because we are tired of fighting or have run out of money to do so, but one based on our Creator's Will, that we love one another.
ReplyDeleteWearing medals not earned by the wearer itself is a total disrespectful of the person who earned it and much so paid his dear life for depending their country. Maybe a special suitcase or a special box to display it will do.
ReplyDeleteI know the actor Russell Crowe wore his grandfather's medal to the Academy Awards one year, which I thought was very classy.
ReplyDeleteThe idea of someone impersonating a decorated veteran, however--which I believe is called "stolen valor"--is a pretty craven offense.
insertAudioReply('initiativestain:video:509','upload-initiativestain-509','');
ReplyDeleteinsertAudioReply('initiativestain:video:510','upload-initiativestain-510','');
ReplyDeleteIt has been a question of recent. Yet what amazes me is that most take medals with them when they are buried.
ReplyDeleteOn the other hand I can appreciate why a family would wish to keep them.
The creator forgot or took a time out during Normandy. I lost three uncles to it all.
ReplyDeleteFor myself I believe that there are merits as such and again I say Lest We Forget.
ReplyDeleteI shall after 11 - 11 - 11..
http://www.thestarphoenix.com/news/RCAF+pilot+penned+famous+poem+receive+tribute/5691851/story.html
ReplyDeleteI don't think he nor anyone as a kid knew that Normandy was what
ReplyDeleteit would be...yet he survived.
No one likes wars yet we have been within wars since the dawn of mankind. ' jgs
ReplyDelete'The high untrespassed sanctity of space' . Loved that quote. There is really something up there, the sacredness of the space, that a soul feels when your actually up ang flying high. the blueness of the vask skies. the perfect blue as i lovely call it. A wonderful poem that could only penned by someone who has truly loved flying.
ReplyDeleteinsertAudioReply('initiativestain:video:511','upload-initiativestain-511','');
ReplyDeleteI have no qualms on writing from where I live - none.
ReplyDeleteinsertAudioReply('initiativestain:video:512','upload-initiativestain-512','');
ReplyDeletehmm ... Anyways thanks Jack. tight hugs Jack
ReplyDeleteI wonder if it's always disrespect although I understand the law in some ways.
ReplyDeleteWhat it you lost your biggest love in a war and that is all you have is a pin perhaps, would it be so wrong to wear it? I know as a women when wars come you may not want your man to go and you know when men go off sometimes one won't come back. And there is nothing you can do. Maybe the one you love. I know that well. And sometimes holding on to these things for a time helps
I do believe if I could have my way everyone would lay down their weapons but I also know many wouldn't have the freedoms we do today if it hadn't been for these men and women who stood up for freedom.~ Lest We Forget ~ How much we need them.......
It's not a perfect world and many thirst for power over others.
A blog of much thought, Jack.
Thank you Haddy....
ReplyDelete